Thursday, October 12, 2017

Audio Snobbery - When did that happen?



I've been looking at online reviews and comments about some gear i'm thinking about getting for my studio rig. I'll admit that i've been pretty shocked and confused by most of what i've read. On sites like Gearslutz, people are really giving some gear a bashing and pour praise on other gear, often with nothing to back it up other than 'i really like it and wouldn't use anything else' kind of comments.

I probably have quite a different background to most of the people who post on these sites. Like a lot of people into making music in the late 80s and early 90s, i started with a cassette-based 4-Track recorder. I added a compressor, a reverb unit and some other effects before i made a massive leap. In 1990 i started working at a top London recording studio. I was using an SSL E-Series, an SSL G-Series and all the usual outboard popular at the time - 1176, LA2A, Pultec, GML and of course, the ubiquitous Lexicon reverbs and ever present Larc controller. These 'professional'  tools were my everyday workhorses. They were a world away from the 4-Track studio i was used to, but they were also very similar, in that i had to learn how to get the best out of them.  Back in those days, the SSL Bus compressor was often bypassed for something else... strange to think of it now, but we would often look for something 'better'. The SSL EQ was also was considered very harsh sounding by a lot of the older engineers who were used to vintage Neves or Trident consoles. Young engineers like myself loved the SSL as it sounded like the records made at the time. Having compressors and gates on every channel was still a treat (most studios didn't have dozens of compressors) and the recall, although very tedious and hit and miss, was a godsend for the record labels who could now send you back to tweak a mix without fear of never getting the same mix back. To be honest, the scribbled notes about the outboard settings meant that mixes always sounded a bit different, but they were closer than was possible before recall. Then there was automation...wow... that really changed mixing. Being able to do multiple passes, tweaking EQ and effects throughout the mix was a big deal.

I eventually went back to working in a smaller studio and spent 5 years working on 8-Track Reel-to-Reels, 16-Tracks and eventually digital tape systems before moving to PCs and then Macs.



Fast forward to 2017 and after spending the last 27 years slowly moving between in-the-box production and sticking to using real studios for recording drum sessions and sometimes final mix sessions on a trusty SSL E-Series, i think i'm in a good position to make some observations on the current trend for bashing anything which isn't an esoteric piece of expensive hardware.

First of all, there is a huge obsession with convertors. Some convertors have specs which far out-perform others, but that doesn't always translate into a better sound. I used an M-Audio PCI soundcard for years and did many mixes which were released and no one ever questioned the quality...and yes, i did record vocals into the card and mix within the box.  Would an Apogee or Avid soundcard have made my mixes better? I don't think so.  I have A/B'd several current soundcards and yes, some sound nicer than others, but i don't hear anything so awful that someone who really knows how to mix won't be able to work with it. It's less of an issue than a lot of people would have you believe. Still, the advice is, buy the best you can afford that has the features you need and just get on with making music.

What about fancy compressors like the UREI 1176? I love them...  nothing sounds better on vocals in my opinion. But... some of the software versions sound so close (i would struggle to choose correctly in a blind test) that i think spending nearly two grand on a real one is crazy unless you really have that kind of spare cash lying around... in that case - why not? They will hold their value. Interestingly, i had a conversation about this exact subject the other day and me and the other engineer came to the same conclusion: The reason studios didn't and don't have more than a few 1176's in their racks is because you can't use them on everything! All those subtle distortion harmonics add together to create a really nasty mush which will ruin any mix. Use one on your lead vocal, maybe a guitar or two and possibly the drum overheads... but that's enough. So, bearing this in mind, maybe it's better to buy a real one rather than a plug-in if you can afford it? Food for thought....

I've been looking at buying a bus compressor. Having just mixed an album on an old SSL E-Series, i kind of fell in love all over again with the bus compressor. The software versions i have are not quite as good. I can make them sound very very close by inserting something like the NLS Bus in front of them and adjusting the input level and then inserting a stereo width expander and adding a tiny bit of widening to the signal.... it's definitely very close. But, i have been testing modern copies of the SSL Bus compressor and i've found a couple which i prefer. They aren't the same... none of the copies are... but they sound great in their own right, and that's what i'm looking for.

Finally, what would the engineers and producers i worked with back in 1990 make of mixing in the box with plug-ins and totally accurate automation and recall? They would drop their analogue consoles and run for the Macs and PCs without a doubt. Everyone conveniently forgets the noisy patchbays, the earth hums, the scratchy pots and the sheer amount of hiss generated by all that analogue gear with the expensive racks of Dolby processors to try and deal with it....

Anyway, stop listening to studio snobbery and learn to mix. A great mix can be done on really basic plug-ins and it can absolutely be good enough to be released... don't let anyone tell you any different.

S




Monday, May 22, 2017

The White Room - Cannes Trailer 2017

It's been a mad week here... i'm still working on 'The White Room'... there's a couple more scenes to shoot and although we've got a rough edit together, there's still a lot of post production to come. I've also been really busy with my other job... music management. We've got our first shows this week since i've taken on the role and then the summer really kicks into gear with shows every week, often more than one. It's festival season and that means jetting around Europe and bussing around the UK with the band. Can't wait...   then there's planning for 2018 - it's all happening now.

But, Emily Wyatt, (lead in 'The White Room') is in Cannes this week and got in touch to see if i could put a trailer together for her to show to interested parties while she's there. So... cue a late night with FCPX.

It's not perfect by any means... there's lots of work still to do, but it gives a rough idea of what we've been up to.  I hope you enjoy it...


Friday, April 28, 2017

The White Room



A couple of weeks ago, i shot a new feature. Called 'The White Room', it's a psychological drama starring Emily Wyatt as a soldier suffering from PTSD who becomes agoraphobic.

We shot 90% of the project in 6 days. How?

Well, i used 2 cameras...and i only used one lens on each. Both zooms. No changing lenses, no messing with camera rigs... 2 rigs, pick one for each shot and get on with it. Also, we had no sound man, no boom and no crew... just me and the actors. The cast comprises of just 4 actors with only 2 on screen at any one time. Also, the whole thing was shot in one location - which was indoors and had been pre-lit with mostly practical lights and daylight. Nothing to move between shots apart from the camera.

Which cameras?

The Sony A7S combined with the Atomos Shogun, shooting 4K Pro Res HQ.

The Lumix GH4 combined with the Atomos Shogun, also shooting 4K Pro Res HQ.

The GH4 was on my Came-TV Mini2 Gimbal and the A7S was mounted in my Movofilms Rig.

One tripod. A Came-TV slider (only used in one scene) and a AKG C568 attached to both rigs picking up what little dialogue there was.

I'm really pleased with the footage. We're in the process of putting the edit together at the moment.

There's one more day of shooting to come and then some extensive work by Jon Atkinson to compose and record the score once we're happy with the edit.

We used the Shotlist App to keep us on track during the shoot. It's so easy to know what's left to do when you're working on indie projects using this app. Due to the availability of the actors we had to shoot out of sequence and there were several scenes where shooting in order would have been very tricky for Emily who had to really experience some pretty harrowing and dark moments. We found getting these done as soon as possible worked best so that we could be sure we had the energy they needed.

Shooting 4K Pro Res HQ swallowed up a lot of HD space, but as we had my edit rig there the whole time, we regularly backed up during each shoot day. But - we did have one disaster. For reasons i still don't understand, one of the SSD drives from the Shogun corrupted all the files on it! We could see it had Pro Res files on it, but nothing could read them. We ended up re-shooting everything that we lost, which in hindsight was pretty easy. Once you've already decided on camera placement and how the lines should be delivered and blocking etc, it's actually really fast just to re-shoot. Massive props to Emily and Sadie for their help on that... i was pretty close to losing my shit...  hate hardware fuck-ups!  Anyway...  it all ended up fine. I have a feeling that maybe the drive was removed from the Shogun at a bad time or maybe it was fried by the caddy when i connected it to the Mac? No idea... i'll have to keep an eye on this.


Check out some stills from the shoot....

Emily Wyatt

Emily Wyatt - and some lovely vertical lens flare from the window

Liam Thomas

Sadie Tonks and Emily Wyatt



Sunday, March 5, 2017

New Challenges...

I'm getting pretty bad at this... no posts in ages - sorry.  I appreciate the continued support and number of you who visit the blog. Hopefully, i'll find more time over the next few months to post something you might actually want to read.

So - last time i talked about a new career change and a new film project... i guess i should talk a bit about that.

The new film project is really exciting to me. I've spent a long time writing various feature screenplays recently and one of those is moving forwards (albeit, quite slowly), but the project i'm shooting in April is really quite different.

There's not much in the way of a script. The idea has come from mashing various real-life experiences i've been through together and then making them happen to someone that isn't me. In fact the protagonist isn't much like me....apart from deep on the subconscious level.  Because there's very little dialogue, i've just used scene descriptions and visual cues to outline what we need to shoot. There's 4 specific conversations in the film which i have scripted, but everything else will be worked out on location.  The cast is basically one person....with 2 very small other roles.  The most exciting thing to me is that we're totally not making any plans for it. There's no distributor involved, there's no investors apart from us and there's no real need for it to be a feature.... if it works better as a long-ish short, then that's what it will be.  I have a feeling all this freedom combined with the very real stories it is based on will make it quite special.  We're shooting in April.




In my last post i also mentioned my new company. I have started an artiste management company. As many of you know, for the last 27 years i have been a sound engineer working for various music artistes and for the last 16 years i have been working for the awesome Kim Wilde. Well, at the end of 2016, Kim's manager decided to retire from the business.  I've been looking for a new direction for my music career and this immediately seemed like the perfect opportunity for me. Luckily for me, Kim believed that i could do this and now i'm her manager. So far it's been really good. It's definitely challenging, but i'm loving it. Hopefully it will continue this way and i'll develop my skills in management alongside my filmmaking.

That's about it for now. I've got some new filmmaking toys coming soon for the new project, so i might do some video reviews....

S